Bath County's Jailyn Ford was named the Player of the Year and James River's John Shotwell was selected as the Coach of the Year on the 2011 All-Pioneer District Softball Team.

2011 All-Pioneer District Softball Team
 
Player of the Year: Jailyn Ford, Bath County
Coach of the Year: John Shotwell, James River

First Team
Taylor Statome, James River
Jordan Frango, Craig County
Amanda Shifflet, Bath County
Ashton Beverley, Parry McCluer
Brittany Keyser, Covington
Melia Hutton, Craig County
Haley Shotwell, James River
Casie Hill, James River
Jenna Sprinkle, James River
Bekkah Pauley, Bath County
Brittney Ratliff, Craig County

Second Team
Kayla Harmon, PM
Jessica Simmons, JR
Emily Bartley, BC
Brandi Dorey, PM
Kristina Huffman, COV
Shanna Woodward, COV
Logan Sizemore, COV
Hannah Morrow, JR
Brandi Clark, PM
Emily Botkin, Highland
Danielle Rock, Craig
Hope Falls, Jr

Honorable Mention
Cindy Hall, Highland
Burgandy Hicks, Highland
Ashley Hiner, Highland
Dee Seaman, JR
Jess O’Connor, BC
Mikaylah Miller, Bath
Olivia Cole, Craig
Courtney Hood, PM
Racheal Crowder, PM
Elizabeth Surface, Craig